The Seventh Function of Language by Laurent Binet – #MBI2018 Review

seventhfunction

The Seventh Function of Language is often described as “The Da Vinci Code Meets _________” (fill in the blank with something higher brow than The Da Vinci Code). I have one too: The Seventh Function of Language is what would happen if David Foster Wallace wrote The Da Vinci Code. Google tells me that David Foster Wallace and Dan Brown attended the same creative writing class at Amherst college, so this collaboration isn’t even as far fetched as it sounds!

The Seventh Function of Language is a buddy cop-murder mystery-political thriller, but it’s also a satirical-but-loving look at French critical theory and post-structuralism in the 1980s. If put on the spot, I would not be able to give a satisfactory definition of either of those things, but one concept that’s relatively easy to grasp is Roland Barthes’ “death of the author”, introduced in his 1967 essay of the same name, that argues that the author’s intentions don’t matter as much as the reader’s. The book opens with the literal death of Barthes – he was run over by a laundry truck in 1980, just after he met with François Mitterrand, who went on to be President of France. In the real world, Barthes’ death was ruled an accident, but Binet asks us to imagine that it wasn’t, that instead it was an assassination, and that every prominent thinker, linguist, writer, and political figure of the time might be involved in a race to learn the secret “seventh function of language”, which would allow the practitioner to persuade anyone to do anything.

Car chases, bombings, poison umbrella stabbings, orgies, and dismemberment ensue.

The book was hilarious and scathing in it’s critique of this moment in French academic history, and I loved how the characters would sometimes realize that they were probably in a novel (and remark that the writer must not be very good, or was using too many cliches). But it didn’t quite land with me – it was missing a few elements. In my Booktube review, I compared it to a few other books that covered similar ground, with somewhat more effective results. Here’s a quick summary, but please tune in for more ramblings and probably-incorrect French pronunciations.

  • Searching for Petronius Totem by Peter Unwin: this book is very similar in subject and tone. Unwin is very interested in the death of the author and the death of the book, and by setting his satirical tale in modern day Canada, I not only understood more of the jokes, but got to consider some very modern literary issues. Namely, how to deal with authors behaving badly, and how technology is affecting (or killing?) literary culture.
  • Come Barbarians series by Todd Babiak: Babiak’s series is set in 1990s Paris, and anti-hero Christopher Kruse also becomes embroiled in political intrigue and murder. These are more straightforward thrillers, but Babiak manages to create a character with such depth, it becomes more that just a “whodunnit”. Binet creates a pair of main characters to guide the reader through the heady world for French semiotics, a detective and a professor, and while they serve that purpose very well, they never became more than literary devices. Meanwhile, I’m so enamored with Mr. Kruse that I’ve embarrassed myself in front of the (local) author more than once… still waiting on the third book in this series!
  • The Sellout by Paul Beatty: no thematic or time-and-place parallels here, but The Sellout maintains a relentless pace that The Seventh Function of Language approached, but couldn’t quite achieve. A satire of race relations in America, Beatty packs every sentence with jokes and wordplay. It made my head spin, in a good way. Binet gets off some great one-liners, and creates some deliciously uncomfortable scenarios for his characters to play out, but these are often followed by a section that drags. It just doesn’t soar the way Beatty’s writing does.

If you watch the video below, you’ll get a bonus middle-grade recommendation for young semioticians. In the meantime, watch for this one to make the shortlist, but it won’t be my pick to win.

A few more reviews and articles to check out:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Advertisements

11 comments

  1. Kat

    This sounds fascinating: how comical to satirize the death of the author and the death of Barthes in a quasi-thriller! (I tried to read The Sellout but unfortunately there were so many Latin errors I had to give up.)

  2. mytwostotinki

    Interestingly, you are posting this almost on the same day when Julia Kristeva (also a character in this book) was exposed as former agent of the Bulgarian State Security. I am wondering if Binet knew something about her that the public learned only now. And the truck that ran Barthes over was a Bulgarian one…coincidence or more?

    • fulcherkim

      Yes that true story re Kristeva coming out is quite incredible. Publicly – and before this story – Binet had cited this as something he simply made up, in part so he could get in the Bulgarian umbrella assassins

      “And remember the umbrellas with poisoned tips? There are records of Bulgarian spies targeting dissidents this way around that time, I didn’t make that up. The Bulgarian secret service was very active. As Julia Kristeva is of Bulgarian origin, I fabricated the connection.”
      http://www.partisanmagazine.com/blog/2015/12/4/an-interview-with-laurent-binet

  3. Bellezza

    I’m saving this until.one of the last on my list; if it’s anything even vaguely like The Sellout, I’ll loathe it. I did, however, enjoy your review. 🙂

  4. Michael @ Knowledge Lost

    I’m reading and loving this book, I always find it weird that this book is compared to Dan Brown, I don’t see it. But then I find it funny that some people compare it to Dan Brown and others think this book is pretentious. I want to read that Todd Babiak series, I think I put it on my wishlist because of you (when you were reading Son of France, I added Come Barbarians).

  5. BestLisette

    I see you don’t monetize your page, don’t waste your
    traffic, you can earn additional bucks every month because you’ve got hi quality content.

    If you want to know how to make extra $$$, search for: Ercannou’s essential adsense alternative

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s